Homemade Peanut Butter Cup Ice Cream: The Creamiest Recipe You’ll Ever Make

There are few things as universally loved as ice cream. And when you combine the silky smooth texture of homemade ice cream with the irresistible flavor of peanut butter and chunks of beloved peanut butter cups, you create a dessert experience that’s truly out of this world. This recipe for **Peanut Butter Cup Ice Cream** delivers a rich, creamy peanut butter base generously studded with chopped peanut butter cups. Whether you prefer to enjoy it immediately as a luxurious soft serve or freeze it for a harder, perfectly scoopable treat, this recipe promises pure delight.

The Eternal Debate: Ice Cream Lover, Year-Round or Seasonal?

For some, ice cream is a year-round staple, an anytime indulgence that defies the weather. My kids, for instance, fall squarely into this camp. To them, there’s simply no ‘wrong’ time for a scoop (or two!). Whether it’s the dead of winter or the height of summer, ice cream is always on the menu.

I, however, tend to be more seasonal in my dessert preferences. Winter calls for warm, comforting foods – hearty soups, rich stews, and hot cocoa to chase away the chill. The thought of a frozen treat when it’s freezing outside just doesn’t quite hit the same. But once the warmer months roll around, it’s a completely different story. As soon as the sun shines brighter and the temperatures rise, I crave all the frozen delights I can get my hands on, and at the top of that list is always homemade ice cream.

The joy of a cool, creamy spoonful on a hot day is unparalleled. It’s a taste of summer, a moment of pure refreshment. And this Peanut Butter Cup Ice Cream recipe is designed to be the ultimate summer indulgence, though I wouldn’t blame you if you found yourself craving it in the middle of November too!

From Churning Chores to Effortless Creaminess: My Ice Cream Maker Journey

I’ve always harbored a deep love for making ice cream from scratch. There’s something incredibly satisfying about transforming simple ingredients into a luscious frozen dessert. However, for many years, this passion was accompanied by a fair amount of hassle. My “old” ice cream maker, a trusty companion for over two decades, was the kind that demanded a hefty supply of ice and rock salt. Not only was it a noisy contraption that forced you to leave the room just to hear yourself think, but even after all that effort, the ice cream still required additional freezing time to reach a truly solid, scoopable consistency. It was certainly an upgrade from the hand-crank machines of my childhood – those huge, hot pink behemoths that turned ice cream making into a true arm workout – but it still felt more like a chore than a joyful culinary adventure.

Even the popular no-churn ice cream recipes, while eliminating the need for special equipment, came with their own set of drawbacks. The waiting game, for hours on end, as the mixture slowly solidified in the freezer, often felt like an eternity when a craving struck. I yearned for a method that combined the convenience of modern appliances with the quality of homemade goodness.

Embracing Innovation: The Game-Changing Cuisinart Ice Cream Maker

Finally, I decided it was time to take the plunge and invest in a new ice cream maker. After polling my friends on Facebook for recommendations, the response was overwhelmingly in favor of the Cuisinart Ice Cream Maker. And let me tell you, it has completely revolutionized my homemade ice cream experience. There is so much to love about this incredible machine!

Firstly, its compact size is a dream. Despite its smaller footprint, it still effortlessly produces a generous 1 1/2 quarts of ice cream, perfect for family desserts or sharing with friends. But perhaps the most surprising and welcome feature is how incredibly quiet it is. Gone are the days of a rumbling machine dominating the kitchen – you can barely hear this one running, allowing for peaceful ice cream making.

And the best part? No more ice or rock salt! This alone is a huge game-changer. I can now save my precious ice for refreshing drinks, rather than sacrificing it to a noisy, messy churner. The convenience factor is through the roof.

Another clever design element is the hole at the top of the lid. While primarily intended for adding extra goodies towards the end of the churning cycle, my family and I have discovered it serves another, equally important purpose: discreet “sampling” of our delicious creations. Just a few quick taste tests, purely to ensure there’s enough flavor, of course (wink, wink!). It’s a fun little perk that adds to the enjoyment of the entire process.

The Irresistible Inspiration: Peanut Butter Cups Galore!

When I first flipped through the instruction manual for my new Cuisinart, brimming with exciting recipes, the idea for **Peanut Butter Cup Ice Cream** immediately jumped off the page. The timing couldn’t have been more perfect, primarily because I had, perhaps, acquired an abundance of peanut butter cups during an after-Easter clearance sale. (Can one truly have *too many* peanut butter cups? Debatable, but I certainly had a healthy stash.)

The thought of transforming those delightful chocolate and peanut butter treats into a rich, creamy ice cream was simply too tempting to resist. It’s a flavor combination that evokes pure joy and nostalgia for many, and bringing it to life in a homemade ice cream felt like the perfect way to celebrate my new appliance and tackle my peanut butter cup surplus.

Tips for Perfect Peanut Butter Cup Ice Cream

Making this incredible ice cream is straightforward, but a few simple tips can elevate your experience and ensure a fantastic result:

• Chopping Peanut Butter Cups: This might sound trivial, but for perfectly chopped cups that don’t roll all over your cutting board, try turning them bottom-side up before you start chopping. The flat, often slightly sticky, chocolate base will help anchor them in place. Also, and this is crucial for quality control, be sure to “test” a few pieces – just to make absolutely certain they’re fresh and delicious!
• Chilling is Key: Don’t skip the refrigeration step for the ice cream base. A thoroughly chilled mixture (2-3 hours or even overnight) is essential for achieving the creamiest texture in your ice cream maker. The colder the base, the faster and better it will churn.
• Adding the Goodies: Introduce the chopped peanut butter cups towards the end of the churning cycle, typically in the last 5 minutes. This ensures they are evenly distributed throughout the ice cream without getting completely obliterated.
• Soft Serve or Scoopable: The beauty of homemade ice cream is its versatility. You can enjoy this Peanut Butter Cup Ice Cream immediately after churning for a delightful soft-serve experience. If you prefer a firmer, more scoopable consistency, transfer it to a freezer-safe container and freeze for an additional 1-2 hours.
• Dealing with Firmness: Be warned, this ice cream gets *hard* in the freezer! If you’ve frozen it for several hours or overnight, be sure to let your ice cream sit out on the counter for 15-20 minutes before attempting to scoop. This brief softening period will make it much easier to serve and enjoy its creamy texture.

Ready to Make Your Own Peanut Butter Cup Ice Cream?

This recipe is a testament to the fact that homemade desserts, especially ice cream, are always the most rewarding. The rich, nutty flavor of the peanut butter base, combined with the delightful textural contrast of the chopped peanut butter cups, creates a truly unforgettable treat. It’s perfect for satisfying that sweet tooth, impressing guests, or simply enjoying a moment of creamy bliss.

So, gather your ingredients, fire up your ice cream maker, and prepare to indulge in the best Peanut Butter Cup Ice Cream you’ve ever tasted!

Connect with Chocolate, Chocolate and More!

Facebook | Twitter | Google+ | Pinterest | instagram

Peanut Butter Cup Ice Cream Recipe

Ingredients

• 1 cup creamy peanut butter
• 2/3 cup sugar
• 1 cup whole milk
• 1 3/4 cup heavy cream
• 1 teaspoon vanilla extract
• 1 cup chopped peanut butter cups

Instructions

1. In a mixing bowl, combine peanut butter and sugar on low speed until smooth. Add milk and mix until sugar is dissolved.
2. Stir in heavy cream and vanilla until blended.
3. Cover and refrigerate for 2-3 hours (or overnight) until mixture is completely chilled.
4. When ready to make Ice Cream, place mixture in Ice Cream maker and freeze according to manufacturer’s instructions. 5 minutes before ice cream is done freezing, add in chopped peanut butter cups.
5. Serve as soft serve immediately or transfer to a freezer-safe container and freeze for 1-2 hours for a firmer ice cream.

Did you make this recipe?

Please leave a comment on the blog or share a photo on Instagram

Craving More Creamy Delights? Explore Our Other Ice Cream Recipes!

If you’ve fallen in love with homemade ice cream, you’re in luck! We have a collection of other fantastic recipes to keep your freezer stocked with deliciousness. Each offers a unique flavor profile, ensuring there’s something for every ice cream enthusiast.

Fresh Strawberry Ice Cream: A vibrant and refreshing classic, bursting with the natural sweetness of ripe strawberries. Simple, elegant, and utterly delicious.

Praline Pecan Fudge Swirl Ice Cream: Indulge in a rich, buttery ice cream base swirled with crunchy praline pecans and luscious fudge. A truly decadent experience!

 

Mint Chocolate Chip Ice Cream: A cool, refreshing classic elevated with plenty of mint flavor and generous chunks of chocolate, including Andes Mints for an extra special touch.

Rich Chocolate Ice Cream: For the true chocolate lover, this custard-based recipe guarantees an incredibly smooth, creamy, and intensely flavorful chocolate experience.

And don’t forget to check out these fantastic ice cream creations from our friends:

Strawberry Cookies and Cream Ice Cream from RecipeGirl: A delightful twist on a classic, combining fruity strawberry with crunchy cookie bits.

Chocolate Chip Cookie Ice Cream from Love from the Oven: Imagine your favorite chocolate chip cookies transformed into a frozen delight, perfect for cones.

Millionaire Ice Cream from Barefeet in the Kitchen: A truly luxurious ice cream featuring rich caramel, chocolate, and pecans for an opulent dessert.