Rich & Creamy Coffee Ice Cream with Dark Chocolate Flecks: A Homemade Dream

Prepare to fall in love with this intensely flavorful Coffee Ice Cream with Dark Chocolate Flecks. It’s a true celebration for any coffee enthusiast, offering a deep, robust coffee flavor beautifully complemented by tiny, delightful bursts of dark chocolate. This isn’t just ice cream; it’s a gourmet experience made accessible for your home kitchen, promising to transport your taste buds to a state of pure bliss with every spoonful.

My journey to perfecting this irresistible coffee ice cream began with a memorable trip to Santa Barbara, California, just a couple of months ago. I had the wonderful privilege of gathering with some incredible blog friends, and it was an experience filled with camaraderie, stunning scenery, and, most importantly, amazing food. The company was genuinely some of the best people I know, including Dorothy from Crazy for Crust, Julianne from Beyond Frosting, Lindsay from Love, Life and Sugar, Hayley the Domestic Rebel, Jen from Yummy Healthy Easy, Debra from Taste and Tell, and Krista from Joyful Healthy Eats.

As food bloggers, our gracious hosts (Dorothy, Julianne, and Lindsay) ensured we were treated to an array of the finest local cuisine available. While every meal was delightful, one particular culinary discovery left an indelible mark on me: McConnell’s Dairy. Perhaps it was the nostalgia of my grandparents’ dairy farm, but more accurately, it was the sheer perfection of their ice cream that captured my heart. McConnell’s is renowned for its rich, artisanal ice cream made with high-quality ingredients, and their coffee flavor was nothing short of extraordinary.

I genuinely fell head over heels for all their flavors, but the coffee ice cream was my absolute favorite. I even justified having it for breakfast one morning, reasoning that, well, it is coffee after all! That experience ignited a mission: I knew I had to come home and recreate some of their incredible flavor combinations, starting with that unforgettable coffee ice cream. The depth of flavor, the creamy texture – it was a standard I aimed to achieve in my own kitchen.

Crafting Homemade Perfection: My Shortcut to Coffee Ice Cream

Replicating the magic of a full-fledged dairy like McConnell’s at home can be a daunting task. Without a commercial dairy at my disposal, and with a desire to make this ice cream recipe genuinely accessible and easy for home cooks, I embraced a few strategic shortcuts. These are methods that McConnell’s, with their artisanal approach, would likely never take, but they don’t compromise on flavor or creamy texture for a fantastic homemade result.

The Secret to Intense Coffee Flavor: High-Quality Instant Coffee

While one could meticulously steep whole coffee beans to extract the deepest, most complex coffee flavor, modern advancements offer a brilliant alternative: high-quality instant coffee. Brands like Starbucks now provide instant coffee that boasts a surprisingly rich and authentic coffee profile. Opting for instant coffee makes this recipe incredibly straightforward, saving time without sacrificing that essential bold coffee taste. It dissolves easily, blends seamlessly into the base, and provides a consistent flavor every time. This shortcut is a game-changer for homemade ice cream, delivering convenience without compromise.

When you first mix the instant coffee with sugar and milk, the color might appear quite dark and intense. Don’t let this deep hue deter you! Once the heavy cream is incorporated into the mixture, it will lighten up considerably. Rest assured, this lightening won’t diminish the robust, rich coffee flavor we’re aiming for. It’s simply the magic of combining all those creamy ingredients to create the perfect base for your ice cream.

The Perfect Pairing: Dark Chocolate Flecks

The same principle of thoughtful ingredient choice applies to the chocolate. I have always found that dark chocolate and coffee are an absolutely divine pairing. The slight bitterness and intense cocoa notes of dark chocolate perfectly complement the earthy depth of coffee. In my freezer, I just might have a Hershey’s Special Dark Candy Bar (or three) at all times, precisely for moments like this. And here’s a little trick: cheese graters aren’t just for cheese! They are fantastic for creating delicate chocolate flecks.

McConnell’s coffee ice cream is known for being speckled with chocolate, not containing large, chunky chocolate chips. This subtle integration of chocolate is what we’re aiming for to achieve that sophisticated balance of flavors and textures. However, I won’t judge if you prefer to use mini chocolate chips – make it your own! The key is to add the chocolate shavings or chips just before the ice cream is fully ready in your machine. This timing ensures they are evenly distributed throughout the creamy base without sinking to the bottom or becoming too hard.

From Churner to Spoon: Enjoying Your Homemade Creation

Normally, when I make homemade ice cream, I transfer it to a container and freeze it for a few hours to achieve a firmer, more scoopable consistency. But with this particular Coffee Ice Cream with Dark Chocolate Flecks, it didn’t stand a chance! The moment it came out of the ice cream maker, it was absolutely irresistible. We devoured it as soft-serve, enjoying its wonderfully creamy texture and intense flavor right away.

I had secretly hoped the kids wouldn’t be as fond of the coffee flavor, leaving more for me. Not a chance! This ice cream was a universal hit. I even had to save a small bowl for my son, who wasn’t home when it was made, ensuring he could have a taste of this exquisite treat. Its widespread appeal is a testament to its perfect balance of robust coffee and delicate chocolate. Whether you prefer it soft and creamy straight from the churner or firmer after a few hours in the freezer, this ice cream is guaranteed to be a crowd-pleaser.

Recipe: Coffee Ice Cream with Dark Chocolate Flecks

Connect with Chocolate Chocolate and More!

Facebook | Twitter | Google+ | Pinterest | instagram

Coffee Ice Cream with Dark Chocolate Flecks

Ingredients

• 2/3 cup sugar
• 2-3 Tablespoons instant coffee
• 1 cup whole milk
• 2 teaspoons vanilla extract
• 2 cups heavy cream
• 4 ounces dark chocolate

Instructions

1. Combine sugar and instant coffee in a large bowl. Add milk and with a hand mixer, beat until sugar and coffee are dissolved. Add in vanilla and heavy cream and mix until blended. Chill in refrigerator for 2 hours or more.
2. Add mixture to ice cream maker and freeze according to machine directions.
3. While ice cream is freezing, shave dark chocolate using a cheese grater. Place shaved chocolate in freezer for 10 minutes.
4. 5 minutes before ice cream is done, add chocolate shavings.
5. Serve as soft ice cream or place in freezer safe container and place in freezer for 2-3 hours for a hard ice cream.

Did you make this recipe?

Please leave a comment on the blog or share a photo on Instagram

Just look at all those delicate dark chocolate flecks, perfectly distributed throughout the rich coffee base! Each spoonful promises a delightful combination of textures and flavors that will leave you wanting more.

This is the Ice Cream maker I have and I love it!

Want More Delicious Homemade Ice Cream?

If you’ve enjoyed crafting this Coffee Ice Cream with Dark Chocolate Flecks, you’re in for a treat! The world of homemade ice cream is vast and incredibly rewarding. Here are some more fantastic recipes, both from Chocolate Chocolate and More and from my talented blogger friends, to keep your ice cream maker busy and your freezer stocked with delightful desserts:

Chocolate Butterfinger Ice Cream

Cookies and Cream Ice Cream

Peanut Butter Cup Ice Cream

Oatmeal Chocolate Chip Cookie Ice Cream from Love, Life and Sugar
Peach Maple Walnut Ice Cream from Beyond Frosting
Salted Caramel Peanut Butter Ice Cream from Crazy for Crust